Sunday, June 21, 2020

[a fifth direction]

Cree Medicine Wheel - Circle divided into four quadrants -- top/north quadrant is white, right/east is yellow, bottom/south is red, left/west is black

If you are familiar with Indigenous teachings, you will know that the four directions feature prominently in many of them. 

For example, a Prayer in the Four Directions by Francis Whiskeyjack refers to east as the physical dimension, south the mental dimension, west the emotional, and north the spiritual. 

Other teachings refer to the relationship between the four directions, the four races, the four seasons, and so on. Often these are mapped onto a medicine wheel such as the one shown to the right.


The poet Eduardo C. Corral wrote a poem which had an interesting line in it. After speaking about someone burning sage and facing the four directions, he writes:

Some Mesoamerican elders
believed there’s a fifth direction.

Not the sky or the ground
but the person right next to you.

The fifth direction as the person right next to us... 

Who has been that fifth direction for you? Who has been there in difficult times and in good times? And for whom can you be that fifth direction, that person to turn to?

This idea also reminds me of the movie The Five Elements. Four of the elements are the traditional elements: fire, water, earth and air. The fifth element is -- well, I won't spoil the movie for you, but it is also an unexpected twist. Watch the movie if you enjoy futuristic films that have interesting characters, a good storyline, an amazing opera singer and more -- all without being dystopian. 

Back to Corral's poem: this concept of the fifth direction really moves the directions from the conceptual and abstract (seasons, four aspects of a person, colours, races) and sacred medicines and people and animals in general, to a very real person - the person next to me. That's where, to use one of my late father's phrases, "the rubber hits the road". 


Poem excerpt from "To Francisco X. Alarcón (1954–2016)" by Eduardo C. Corral. 

Saturday, June 20, 2020

[when god made stones]


Here is the first stanza of a stunning poem by Kaitlin Hardy Shetler:


when god made stones
did he decide ahead of time
which ones were made for throwing
did he weigh each one for maximum impact
a stone for the whores
a stone for the gays
 

picture of stones of varying sizes. photo by rob goetze
Read the rest of this poem on Kaitlin's Facebook page:

One of a set of poems by her and others with the tag #poemsfortheresistance

Wednesday, June 17, 2020

the invisibilizer


The Invisibilizer, by rob goetze. First panel shows a diverse group of people on a conveyor belt, heading into a machine labeled "Invisibilizer". Second panel shows only the white man coming out of the machine. One worker says to the other, "No matter what settings I use, I can't get it to make white people invisible..."

The Invisibilizer
While the Invisibilizer is a machine in the cartoon above, it is still is a reality for many marginalized people. The racist, cisheteropatriarchal systems that we live in tend to highlight their own while rendering invisible those who are minoritized. 


Verb
invisiblize (third-person singular simple present invisiblizes, present participle invisiblizing, simple past and past participle invisiblized)

(transitive, chiefly sociology) To make invisible; to marginalize so as to erase the presence or contributions of. Wiktionary.org

Friday, June 12, 2020

[brilliant critique of Vogue's whitewashed covers]


"Being black is not a crime" - Vogue critique by Salma Noor, showing black person in white dress photoshopped onto a Vogue cover, with the words "Being black is not a crime".

"Oslo-based student Salma Noor posted her own version of a Vogue cover on June 2, with the cover line “Being black is not a crime” in support of Black Lives Matter. Noor modeled for the alternative cover herself, with the help of photographer @calvin. Little did she know that the trend would go insanely viral days later—thanks in part to a June 6 internal memo from Vogue‘s editor-in-chief herself, Anna Wintour." (source)

Salma's action started a trend where people of colour did the same, tagging their images with #VogueChallenge. 

Tuesday, June 09, 2020

[social justice books]


Screenshot of Social Justice Books' Booklists page, showing 2 rows of the 10 rows of curated booklists

Social Justice Books calls itself "the best selection of multicultural and social justice books for children, YA and educators," and looking at their site makes it obvious that their claim is true.

The site includes curated booklists, an excellent Guide for Selecting Anti-Bias Children’s Books, and more! The booklists (the above picture 14 of the over 60 booklists available) include almost every culture imaginable as well as broader topics like culture/language, hair, holidays, etc.

Monday, June 01, 2020

what does it mean to celebrate all people?


Sometimes organizations make bold statements in their mission, vision and value statements (and the like). But what do such statements mean? How are they realized (real-alized; made real)? 

I offer this as one example of how one can respectfully ask about such statements, in a way that promotes accountability, provokes thinking, and encourages movement forward.

Last summer I wrote to our parish priest about a statement that was sent out in a key document. Here's my side of the email:



blue-ish bar
Hi P,

I have a question for the leadership regarding the following value from the mission action plan document that was sent out:

Welcoming and Open to All
We will live Christ’s words: “Love your neighbor as yourself.” We will be a welcoming parish family. We love and celebrate all people regardless of age, culture, sexuality, or socio-economic status.

I’m wondering in particular what the last sentence means. Does it mean that we at our church generally celebrate all people without regard or attention to any of these things, even those things like race, culture or sexuality which are unique and something to be specifically celebrated? Kind of like being “colour-blind” where we celebrate all people regardless of their colour but in fact we ignore their colour and their ethnic / racial uniqueness and what they bring to the table and how the community is enriched by them?

Or will we actually celebrate people for who they specifically are, including race, culture and sexuality? Kinda like the way the LGBTQ2S+ community is acknowledged and celebrated particularly in June here in Edmonton, or the way we in our church region are beginning to recognize and celebrate indigenous peoples?


Related to this: two Sundays ago two women were sitting in the row in front of us. Based on their affection and physical contact, I would assume they are a couple and I wondered, how did they know this would be a safe place to be themselves? It's not a reasonable assumption to make about churches, and the public face of our church does not indicate that LGBTQ2S+ people would be welcome. Did they speak to one of the clergy in advance? Do they know someone who attends here? Were they just taking a chance on us and lucked out? I don't know.


Further related to this: P, you preached about a prophetic imagination. How might we imagine a church where all people are truly embraced and seen as an integral and needed part of the body? A church where none are shamed? A church which makes it obvious that people walking in will be loved and embraced? A church that shines its light on a hill instead of hiding it under a bushel?

Warm regards,

Rob




Note: I received a very positive response from our priest, who said that the leadership was discussing this and moving forward to look at specific ways of implementing.